Harry Potter Cookies – Gryffindor Ties

by Lisa Douglas

If you’re a huge fan of Harry Potter like our family, you will adore this Gryffindor Tie Harry Potter Cookies recipe! These are a perfect treat to make for birthday parties or for Harry Potter parties with family, friends, and other Potterheads like us!

Gryffindor Ties Harry Potter Cookies
How to Make Harry Potter Cookies

Harry Potter Cookies – Gryffindor Ties

Well, I’m back at it again with yet another amazing Harry Potter recipe, this time we’ve made sugar cookie Harry Potter Gryffindor Tie Cookies decorated with fondant! With the 20th anniversary of Harry Potter being published this year, I knew I had to do something special and magical to celebrate the Boy Who Lived! I solemnly swear I am up to no good again with this recipe! ⚡️

harry potter gif
Harry Potter Cookies with Gryffindor Ties

Gryffindor Tie Harry Potter Cookies

Aren’t these Gryffindor Tie Cookies absolutely adorable and perfect? If you’re hosting a Harry Potter party or get together, perhaps to binge watch the Harry Potter movies with friends, wouldn’t this be a perfect treat to serve for your friends? Perhaps served alongside my Harry Potter Cupcakes with Gryffindor Scarves!

Gryffindor Tie Harry Potter Cookies

Harry Potter Cookies Recipe

These spellbinding cookies honor J.K. Rowling’s wizarding world masterpieces with Harry Potter and Fantastic Beasts, don’t you think? Using an easy sugar cookie mix and a few important tools to help shape these Gryffindor Ties, you too can create these delightful cookies. Remember, it does not do well to dwell on dreams and forget to live! ⚡️

Harry Potter Gryffindor Tie Cookies

Harry Potter Gryffindor Tie Cookies

These impressive Harry Potter Cookies require no wands to make these wondrous treats! While there are quite a few steps, these Gryffindor Tie Cookies are fairly simple enough with parental supervision for your kids to help you create these for your Potter fans’ next party! These cookies are Harry, Hermione, Ron, and Dumbledore approved! ⚡️

Harry Potter Cookies

Gryffindor Tie Harry Potter Cookies Recipe

Cookies like these are memories in the making. Remember anything’s possible if you’ve got enough nerve! And I say, have the nerve to create these Gryffindor Tie-Inspired Harry Potter Cookies

Harry Potter Cookies - Gryffindor Ties

How to Decorate Harry Potter Cookies

There will be no foolish wand-waving or silly incantations in this recipe! Ready made fondant swoops in and saves the day, making the creation of these Harry Potter Cookies easy-peasy Ron Weasley. Little ones will need your supervision and guidance if you choose to let them help you cut any of the fondant with you.

Harry Potter Cookies Recipe

How to Make Harry Potter Cookies

To make these Gryffindor Tie Inspired Harry Potter Cookies, you will need the following ingredients:

You will also need the following tools:

Ingredients to Make Harry Potter Cookies

Prepare your sugar cookie dough according to your cookie recipe (unless you use store bought roll out dough). For this recipe, you won’t need to use a lot of cookie dough, so you can refrigerate any extra cookie dough for later use, for other cookies, or you can double or triple this recipe! Line a baking sheet with parchment paper. On a floured surface, roll out your cookie dough so that it’s about ¼ of an inch thick. Using your diamond-shaped cookie cutter, cut out twelve cookies.

Cut out diamonds for Harry Potter Cookies

Use a paring knife to cut out a portion of the diamond’s sides, cutting on an angle. You will want the diamond to look thinner and begin to take the shape of a necktie.

Cut diamonds for Harry Potter Cookies

Cut out twelve small rectangles, about ½ an inch in width and ¼ of an inch in length. Place on the top of your cookie necktie to make the tie’s “knot.”

Make Knot for Harry Potter Cookies

Place each cookie on your lined baking sheet and bake according to recipe’s directions, but keep an eye on it as they are smaller and might cook more quickly. Once baked, remove from cookie sheet and cool completely on a wire rack.

Baked Harry Potter Cookies ready to decorate

Color one bowl of your white fondant with the burgundy gel food coloring. Add as much food coloring as you need until you achieve a deep burgundy color. Color the remainder of your fondant with the yellow gel food coloring in the other bowl. Make a small knot shape from the yellow fondant and place on top of the cookie tie.

Fondant Knot for Harry Potter Cookies

Roll out each colored fondant until they’re about ¼ of an inch thick each. Cut out twelve small diamonds using the same size diamond cookie cutter that you cut for tie from each of the colored fondants.

Cut out red fondant diamonds for Harry Potter Cookies

Using the same technique you used to shape the cookies into ties (ie.: with the cookie cutter and the paring knife), cut out twelve necktie shapes out of your burgundy fondant. To do this, lay the burgundy fondant onto the cookie, and trim away the excess. Press the fondant shape onto each cookie once the size is good.

Cut out red fondant for Harry Potter Cookies

Cut out strips from your yellow fondant diamonds and place on top of each cookie. The strips will be too long, that’s alright, just make sure they’re lined up before trimming.

Cut out yellow stripes for Gryffindor Tie Harry Potter Cookies

With your paring knife, trim as needed to match the tie shape with the burgundy fondant.

Cut fondant for Gryffindor Tie Harry Potter Cookies

Repeat for each Gryffindor Tie cookie – annnd you’re done! Serve and enjoy your magical masterpiece!

Harry Potter Cookies with Fondant Gryffindor Ties
Harry Potter Gryffindor Tie Cookies

Harry Potter Cookies – Gryffindor Ties

If you’re a huge Harry Potter fan, you have GOT to make these Gryffindor Tie Harry Potter Cookies recipe! Perfect for parties!
Print Pin Rate
Course: Dessert
Prep Time: 15 minutes
Cook Time: 10 minutes
Total Time: 25 minutes
Servings: 12 cookies

Instructions

  • Make your cookie dough according to your cookie recipe. For this recipe, you’ll need about 5 oz. worth of cookie dough. (Refrigerate any extra cookie dough for later use for other cookies!)
  • Line a baking sheet with parchment paper. On a floured surface, roll out your cookie dough so that it’s about ¼ of an inch thick.
  • Using your diamond-shaped cookie cutter, cut out 12 cookies.
  • Use a paring knife to cut out a portion of the diamond’s sides. Cut out on an angle: you will want the diamond to look thinner and take the shape of a necktie.
  • Cut out 12 small rectangles, about ½ an inch in width and ¼ of an inch in length. Place on the top of your cookie necktie.
  • Place each cookie on your lined baking sheet and bake according to recipe’s directions. Once baked, cool completely on a wire rack.
  • Color 5 oz. of your white fondant with burgundy gel food coloring. Add as much food coloring as you need until you achieve a deep burgundy color.
  • Color the remainder of your fondant with the yellow gel food coloring.
  • Roll out each colored fondant until they’re about ¼ of an inch thick each. Cut out 12 small rectangles (the same size that you cut for the top of your tie), and then press it onto the cookie.
  • Using the same technique you used to shape the cookies into ties (ie.: with the cookie cutter and the paring knife), cut out 12 necktie shapes out of your burgundy fondant. Press the fondant shape onto each cookie.
  • Cut out strips from your yellow fondant and place on top of each cookie. Trim accordingly.
  • Serve and enjoy!
Tried this recipe?Tag me to show me @crazyadventuresinparenting and/or use #MadeItLikedit to be featured on Pinterest!

If you’re feeling particularly Harry Potter inspired and ready to celebrate, check out my other Harry Potter recipes, cupcake recipes and dessert recipes! And “Don’t let the muggles get you down.” ⚡️

Easy Harry Potter Gryffindor Tie Cookies Recipe

You may also like

shares

Sharing is Caring

Help spread the word. You're awesome for doing it!